Page 1 of 1

’87 Redskins w/out Doug Williams

Posted: Mon Oct 12, 2026 6:53 am
by 74_75_78_79_
W/L record in their twelve non-scab games, playoffs, Super Bowl if they still get there, etc? How does it turn out with just Jay under center?

Re: ’87 Redskins w/out Doug Williams

Posted: Mon Oct 12, 2026 8:22 am
by saturdaysarebetter
I don't envision it turns out nearly as well with Jay as their QB. His post-season numbers left a lot to be desired.

Re: ’87 Redskins w/out Doug Williams

Posted: Mon Oct 12, 2026 9:37 am
by 7DnBrnc53
saturdaysarebetter wrote: ↑Mon Oct 12, 2026 8:22 am I don't envision it turns out nearly as well with Jay as their QB. His post-season numbers left a lot to be desired.
I agree. And, I don't know if the team liked him as much.

Another thing to explore: What would have happened if Doug Williams went to the Raiders before the 1987 season.

On the 1987 Redskins America's Game episode, Williams talked about the trade that almost was.

Re: ’87 Redskins w/out Doug Williams

Posted: Mon Oct 12, 2026 1:35 pm
by 74_75_78_79_
saturdaysarebetter wrote: ↑Mon Oct 12, 2026 8:22 am I don't envision it turns out nearly as well with Jay as their QB. His post-season numbers left a lot to be desired.
But he did have quite a game at Soldier in ’86. That, right there, ought to be ‘Exhibit A’ of the Bears being quite off from the year before even though, statistically, they had a better D than ’85 along with losing just one more game that regular season (14-2 instead of 15-1).

If Jay played well in that game, then sure-enough the Redskins with him under center wins again at Soldier in ’87 had they still made it to 3rd-seed. NFCCG vs Minny? IRL it was the defense that won them that one; Pettibone out-Floyd-ing Floyd Peters - Washington putting up the sacks as the Hogs pitched a shutout (zero sacks) against the Sack Master himself!

Given Gibbs & staff along with that O-line and pass-defense, even if Doug overall career-wise (or at least in the ’87 playoffs) was the better QB, Jay ought to get past the Vikes as well along with beating Denver in a non-competetive Super Bowl even if there’d be no wow-ing ‘35-0’ 2nd quarter. Perhaps a boring 27-10 triplet to both SBs XII and XV (Dal/Den, Oak/Phi) it would have been.

And though I always felt it most-likely that San Fran wins in a hypo-CCG match with Washington (and then also demolishing Denver), I don’t feel it should be etched in-stone. Possible that the Redskins pull the (minor; yes, it would be just a minor) upset at Candlestick with Doug, or Jay, each being capable of pulling it off with Gibbs & staff at helm.

Re: ’87 Redskins w/out Doug Williams

Posted: Tue Oct 13, 2026 5:04 am
by Sonny9
7DnBrnc53 wrote: ↑Mon Oct 12, 2026 9:37 am I agree. And, I don't know if the team liked him as much.

Another thing to explore: What would have happened if Doug Williams went to the Raiders before the 1987 season.

On the 1987 Redskins America's Game episode, Williams talked about the trade that almost was.
Players liked Williams better. Also Schroeder was injured a bit and wasn't getting along with management.

That said, the first 2 playoff games Williams was not very good. 14-29 209 1 TD 1 Int 1 lost fumble and 9-26 119 yds 2 TDs

And the Super Bowl? Just about any QB could have won that game easily, as open as the receivers were. Dropped passes by open receivers ended 2 of their first 4 drives. 4 drops in those 4 series

Re: ’87 Redskins w/out Doug Williams

Posted: Tue Oct 13, 2026 6:40 pm
by Brian wolf
We dont know what Schroeder would have done because he was replaced by Williams for throwing interceptions. Doesnt mean he couldnt have beaten the Bears again, or the Vikings and Broncos.

Williams did a good job and had his moment in the sun. 7D felt he was better than Rypien but Rypien led the Skins to three consecutive postseason berths, something Williams couldnt do with TB or Wash ...

Re: ’87 Redskins w/out Doug Williams

Posted: Fri Oct 16, 2026 11:31 pm
by Sonny9
Schroder int rate was 3.7%. Williams was 3.5
The last 5 games with 155 attempts his rate was 4.5%. Williams last 2 games, with 68 attempts his int rate was 4.4%

The players from the start of the season would rather have Williams because Schroeder thought about crossing the picket line in '87 and had an ego problem that turned off his teammates
Gibbs said about the strike to the players, whatever you do, do it together.