Page 1 of 2
Rating the Super Bowl Champions of the 1970s
Posted: Sat Oct 03, 2026 10:49 am
by saturdaysarebetter
I'm currently reading Steve Perkins book, "The Dallas Cowboys - winning the big one," about the 1971 Cowboys. I had recently read his earlier book about the Cowboys, "Next year's Champions."
The '71 Cowboys roster had so many future hall-of-famers on it: Ditka, Staubach, Alworth, Hayes, Wright, Gregg (although he didn't see much action), Adderly, Renfro, Harris, Lilly, Howley along with terrific players like Cornell Green, Lee Roy Jordan, and John Niland as well.
Where do you rate the 1971 Dallas Cowboys in the list of Super Bowl champions of the 1970s? Some might say that's difficult to do, but hey, judges pick from hundreds of beautiful women in beauty pageants to pick the most beautiful woman.
1970 Baltimore Colts
1971 Dallas Cowboys
1972 Miami Dolphins
1973 Miami Dolphins
1974 Pittsburgh Steelers
1975 Pittsburgh Steelers
1976 Oakland Raiders
1977 Dallas Cowboys
1978 Pittsburgh Steelers
1979 Pittsburgh Steelers
Where do you rate the '71 Cowboys in the SB champions of the '70s and what would be your top 10 list?
Re: Rating the Super Bowl Champions of the 1970s
Posted: Sat Oct 03, 2026 11:52 am
by SeahawkFever
saturdaysarebetter wrote: ↑Sat Oct 03, 2026 10:49 am
I'm currently reading Steve Perkins book, "The Dallas Cowboys - winning the big one," about the 1971 Cowboys. I had recently read his earlier book about the Cowboys, "Next year's Champions."
The '71 Cowboys roster had so many future hall-of-famers on it: Ditka, Staubach, Alworth, Hayes, Wright, Gregg (although he didn't see much action), Adderly, Renfro, Harris, Lilly, Howley along with terrific players like Cornell Green, Lee Roy Jordan, and John Niland as well.
Where do you rate the 1971 Dallas Cowboys in the list of Super Bowl champions of the 1970s? Some might say that's difficult to do, but hey, judges pick from hundreds of beautiful women in beauty pageants to pick the most beautiful woman.
1970 Baltimore Colts
1971 Dallas Cowboys
1972 Miami Dolphins
1973 Miami Dolphins
1974 Pittsburgh Steelers
1975 Pittsburgh Steelers
1976 Oakland Raiders
1977 Dallas Cowboys
1978 Pittsburgh Steelers
1979 Pittsburgh Steelers
Where do you rate the '71 Cowboys in the SB champions of the '70s and what would be your top 10 list?
One thing I’ll also add is that this team deserves a lot of credit for averaging 29 points per game, which is one of the highest averages in the 1970’s pre-Mel Blount rule.
As far as comparing them to the other champions of the 1970’s goes, I’d take those Cowboys over at minimum the 1970 Colts (who had a better season in 71, but weren’t as impressive in 1970 from the looks of it), and probably the 1974 Steelers (in my book the weakest of the four Steeler title teams in the 70’s.
I’m torn between the 71 and 77 Cowboys for the number eight and seven spot. Probably where they’d land for me.
Re: Rating the Super Bowl Champions of the 1970s
Posted: Sat Oct 03, 2026 9:01 pm
by 74_75_78_79_
SeahawkFever wrote: ↑Sat Oct 03, 2026 11:52 am
saturdaysarebetter wrote: ↑Sat Oct 03, 2026 10:49 am
I'm currently reading Steve Perkins book, "The Dallas Cowboys - winning the big one," about the 1971 Cowboys. I had recently read his earlier book about the Cowboys, "Next year's Champions."
The '71 Cowboys roster had so many future hall-of-famers on it: Ditka, Staubach, Alworth, Hayes, Wright, Gregg (although he didn't see much action), Adderly, Renfro, Harris, Lilly, Howley along with terrific players like Cornell Green, Lee Roy Jordan, and John Niland as well.
Where do you rate the 1971 Dallas Cowboys in the list of Super Bowl champions of the 1970s? Some might say that's difficult to do, but hey, judges pick from hundreds of beautiful women in beauty pageants to pick the most beautiful woman.
1970 Baltimore Colts
1971 Dallas Cowboys
1972 Miami Dolphins
1973 Miami Dolphins
1974 Pittsburgh Steelers
1975 Pittsburgh Steelers
1976 Oakland Raiders
1977 Dallas Cowboys
1978 Pittsburgh Steelers
1979 Pittsburgh Steelers
Where do you rate the '71 Cowboys in the SB champions of the '70s and what would be your top 10 list?
One thing I’ll also add is that this team deserves a lot of credit for averaging 29 points per game, which is one of the highest averages in the 1970’s pre-Mel Blount rule.
As far as comparing them to the other champions of the 1970’s goes, I’d take those Cowboys over at minimum the 1970 Colts (who had a better season in 71, but weren’t as impressive in 1970 from the looks of it), and probably the 1974 Steelers (in my book the weakest of the four Steeler title teams in the 70’s.
I’m torn between the 71 and 77 Cowboys for the number eight and seven spot. Probably where they’d land for me.
I've always gone back-and-forth with the '71 & '77 Cowboys as well, sometimes tying them, but I think more often than not me giving nod to the former. And right now, at least, is where I'm at on that.
What '77 has got going for them is #1 in both offense and defense! A true great champion, of course, but boy they had a soft post-season slate! Beating Denver, 27-10, is a great feet. That Broncos squad was a true great SB-participant, but not at all what the Steelers were in the surrounding seasons nor at all the '76 Raiders and their squads leading up to that campaign. They weren't as strong as the '71 Dolphins either. I say the '71 Cowboys at least a better team after Wk#7 than the '77 Cowboys were after Wk#7 - how does that sound?
Yes, both teams are likely in the bottom-half of this given list. And nothing to be ashamed of considering the others! '74 Steelers, yes, are the weakest of the Dynasty and at #9 with those '70 Colts, sadly, beneath all '70s champs. At the very least, the '71 Cowboys are at #7. At best they can actually possibly be at
#4 above both Dolphin teams and also the flawed 12-4, but full of
bite, '79 Steelers! But the former is where most of me leans toward. After all, there shouldn't be too much distance between them and '77.
Re: Rating the Super Bowl Champions of the 1970s
Posted: Sun Oct 04, 2026 11:50 pm
by ShinobiMusashi
1. 72 Dolphins
2. 78 Steelers
3. 76 Raiders
4. 73 Dolphins
5. 77 Cowboys
6. 75 Steelers
7. 71 Cowboys
8. 79 Steelers
9. 74 Steelers
10. 70 Colts
Re: Rating the Super Bowl Champions of the 1970s
Posted: Mon Oct 05, 2026 10:26 am
by 7DnBrnc53
1. 1978 Steelers
2. 1975 Steelers
3. 1977 Cowboys
4. 1973 Dolphins
5. 1972 Dolphins
6. 1979 Steelers
7. 1971 Cowboys
8. 1974 Steelers
9. 1976 Raiders
10. 1970 Colts
Also, someone said that the 1977 Broncos weren't as strong as the 1971 Dolphins. Offensively, yes. Defensively, not true. The Orange Crush was better than the No-Names.
Even offensively, though, the 1977 Broncos were OK, and may have been better than the 71 Dolphins in some areas. Morton was a statue, but had a bigger arm than Griese. Odoms was as good, if not better, than Mandich and Marv Fleming at TE. And, while Moses wasn't as good as Warfield at WR1, he was clutch in 1977.
Re: Rating the Super Bowl Champions of the 1970s
Posted: Mon Oct 05, 2026 11:52 am
by Brian wolf
1971 Dolphins offense was much better than Denver in 1977. Denver's offensive line, just like 86-87, was pedestrian.
Re: Rating the Super Bowl Champions of the 1970s
Posted: Mon Oct 05, 2026 12:28 pm
by 7DnBrnc53
Brian wolf wrote: ↑Mon Oct 05, 2026 11:52 am
1971 Dolphins offense was much better than Denver in 1977. Denver's offensive line, just like 86-87, was pedestrian.
I agree with you about the O-line (although the 86-87 lines were a little better than the 77 line), but the Broncos had good receivers in TE Odoms and Moses, and Upchurch had big play speed on the outside. Even Dolbin was decent (they should have drafted Stanley Morgan instead of G Steve Schindler, though).
Re: Rating the Super Bowl Champions of the 1970s
Posted: Mon Oct 05, 2026 2:42 pm
by SeahawkFever
ShinobiMusashi wrote: ↑Sun Oct 04, 2026 11:50 pm
1. 72 Dolphins
2. 78 Steelers
3. 76 Raiders
4. 73 Dolphins
5. 77 Cowboys
6. 75 Steelers
7. 71 Cowboys
8. 79 Steelers
9. 74 Steelers
10. 70 Colts
I’d switch the 75 and 78 Steelers but that’s just me.
One had a better postseason, but the other was better in the regular season and by a bigger margin I might argue.
Re: Rating the Super Bowl Champions of the 1970s
Posted: Mon Oct 05, 2026 2:43 pm
by SeahawkFever
7DnBrnc53 wrote: ↑Mon Oct 05, 2026 10:26 am
1. 1978 Steelers
2. 1975 Steelers
3. 1977 Cowboys
4. 1973 Dolphins
5. 1972 Dolphins
6. 1979 Steelers
7. 1971 Cowboys
8. 1974 Steelers
9. 1976 Raiders
10. 1970 Colts
Also, someone said that the 1977 Broncos weren't as strong as the 1971 Dolphins. Offensively, yes. Defensively, not true. The Orange Crush was better than the No-Names.
Even offensively, though, the 1977 Broncos were OK, and may have been better than the 71 Dolphins in some areas. Morton was a statue, but had a bigger arm than Griese. Odoms was as good, if not better, than Mandich and Marv Fleming at TE. And, while Moses wasn't as good as Warfield at WR1, he was clutch in 1977.
How was the running game of that Broncos team?
And while not the Super Bowl opponent, how would you say the 1971 Vikings and 49ers compare to the 1977 Bears and Vikings?
Re: Rating the Super Bowl Champions of the 1970s
Posted: Mon Oct 05, 2026 4:03 pm
by PaulPFHOF
1. 1978 Pittsburgh Steelers
2. 1972 Miami Dolphins
3. 1975 Pittsburgh Steelers
4. 1971 Dallas Cowboys
5. 1977 Dallas Cowboys
6. 1979 Pittsburgh Steelers
7. 1973 Miami Dolphins
8. 1974 Pittsburgh Steelers
9. 1976 Oakland Raiders
10. 1970 Baltimore Colts