Most baffling All Decade choices

[PFHOFlover]

Here’s my list of the most baffling All Decade choices please note I didn’t include anyone not already in the Pro Football Hall of Fame

1920s

Hunk Anderson-only played four seasons and had only one All Pro

1930s

Cecil Isbell-only played two seasons in the 1930s

Gaynell Tinsley-also played only two seasons in the 1930s

Frank Cope-again only played two seasons in the 1930s

George Svendsen-only played three seasons in the 1930s

1940s

Byron Whizzer White-only played two seasons in the 1940s

Al Blozis-only played three seasons in the 1940s

Bill Edwards-again only played three seasons in the 1940s

1950s

Joe Fortunato-only played five seasons in the 1950s

1960s

Larry Morris-made no Pro Bowls and had only one All Pro

1980s

Dave Butz-made only one Pro Bowl and had only two All Pros one first team the other second team

Carl Banks-made only one Pro Bowl and had only one All Pro

John Anderson-made no Pro Bowls or had any All Pros

[Gary Najman]

1980s

Carl Banks-made only one Pro Bowl and had only one All Pro

John Anderson-made no Pro Bowls or had any All Pros

Rickey Jackson should had been in the team, even Chip Banks.

[Brian wolf]

John Turney knows about all these questionable choices. He helped create the All-Mid Decade teams on Pro Football Journal.
The HOF should acknowledge or honor/accept these teams. Thoroughly thought out and sensible ...

[readjack]

John definitely is the master of all-decade.

I'll add another curious one: Rick Upchurch was the 1980s All-Decade kick returner. His final career kick return? 1979.

[rewing84]

Here’s my list of the most baffling All Decade choices please note I didn’t include anyone not already in the Pro Football Hall of Fame

1920s

Hunk Anderson-only played four seasons and had only one All Pro

1930s

Cecil Isbell-only played two seasons in the 1930s

Gaynell Tinsley-also played only two seasons in the 1930s

Frank Cope-again only played two seasons in the 1930s

George Svendsen-only played three seasons in the 1930s

1940s

Byron Whizzer White-only played two seasons in the 1940s

Al Blozis-only played three seasons in the 1940s

Bill Edwards-again only played three seasons in the 1940s

1950s

Joe Fortunato-only played five seasons in the 1950s

1960s

Larry Morris-made no Pro Bowls and had only one All Pro

1980s

Dave Butz-made only one Pro Bowl and had only two All Pros one first team the other second team

Carl Banks-made only one Pro Bowl and had only one All Pro

John Anderson-made no Pro Bowls or had any All Pros

Maxie Baughan should have gotten the 60's all decade spot over morris 100% Baughan Played the whole decade

[SeahawkFever]

John Turney knows about all these questionable choices. He helped create the All-Mid Decade teams on Pro Football Journal.
The HOF should acknowledge or honor/accept these teams. Thoroughly thought out and sensible ...

Just did a quick search for that; apparently it’s from one year ending in five to the next. (ex: 1995-2005)

I see that one of the guys I nominated a couple years ago for Hall of Very Good who just got in this past year (Wilber Marshall) was on his first team for 85-95, and another player who I could see myself nominating years down the line (Tom Nalen) was the second team center for 95-05.