How can you separate these three?
-
JohnTurney
- Posts: 2292
- Joined: Fri Oct 31, 2014 1:28 pm
How can you separate these three?
Gradishar had a DOPY, Brazile a 2nd team All-Decade...Howley a SB MVP...
Re: How can you separate these three?
Tough one I would say opinions from former players.JohnTurney wrote:Gradishar had a DOPY, Brazile a 2nd team All-Decade...Howley a SB MVP...
-
bachslunch
- Posts: 824
- Joined: Tue Oct 14, 2014 7:09 am
Re: How can you separate these three?
Great argument to put them all in, if you ask me. But it can only be done one at a time (maybe two if one of those "two Senior nominee" years).
Re: How can you separate these three?
I think Howley's career is different in that he was effective at such an advanced age...he was a pro bowler at 35, and still a very good starter at 36. Also, Howley flip-flopped between weak and strongside OLB and was an elite performer on both sides.
Gradishar was the best defensive player on the best defensive team in football at one time (1977 Broncos), which is something Brazile and Howley can't say. Gradishar also has the 1978 DPOY award.
Reading through some old Dr. Z columns in the SI vault, and FWIW he anecdotally said that Brazile was inconsistent and would take plays off, and Howley was the 2nd best coverage OLB behind Jack Ham.
Personally, I always liked Howley and thought he has been overlooked. Was he better than Dave Wilcox? No. Was he better than Dave Robinson? Probably not in terms of 'eliteness'. Was he better than Chris Hanburger? Perhaps. Howley isn't a slam-dunk HOFer, but I think he warrants enshrinement and am 'rooting' for him since there will come a point when none of the HOF voters will remember him. That said, here is how I would rank them:
1) Gradishar
2) Howley
3) Brazile
But I think all would be fine additions to Canton.
Gradishar was the best defensive player on the best defensive team in football at one time (1977 Broncos), which is something Brazile and Howley can't say. Gradishar also has the 1978 DPOY award.
Reading through some old Dr. Z columns in the SI vault, and FWIW he anecdotally said that Brazile was inconsistent and would take plays off, and Howley was the 2nd best coverage OLB behind Jack Ham.
Personally, I always liked Howley and thought he has been overlooked. Was he better than Dave Wilcox? No. Was he better than Dave Robinson? Probably not in terms of 'eliteness'. Was he better than Chris Hanburger? Perhaps. Howley isn't a slam-dunk HOFer, but I think he warrants enshrinement and am 'rooting' for him since there will come a point when none of the HOF voters will remember him. That said, here is how I would rank them:
1) Gradishar
2) Howley
3) Brazile
But I think all would be fine additions to Canton.