Today's (Fairly Easy) Puzzler

[Todd Pence]

This will probably take the members of this group about ten seconds to get, but . . . what distinction do each of the following players from NFL history hold?

Alan Ameche
Red Badgro
Ricky Bell
Jim Benton
Neal Craig
Herwitt Dixon
Elbert Dubenion
Arian Foster
Larry Garron
Red Grange
Ace Gutowsky
Franco Harris
Abner Haynes
Don Hutson
Steve Largent
Jamal Lewis
Verl Lillywhite
Paul Lowe
Rob Lytle
Bill Martin
Eric Martin
Don Maynard
Jim Mitchell
Marion Motley
Dan Reeves
Pug Rentner
Clyde Simmons
Dave Smith
Charlie Trippi
Steve Van Buren
Wesley Walls
Paul Warfield

[ChrisBabcock]

If I may quote Cliff Clavin... "People who have never been in my kitchen."

No, seriously, I'm stumped. Can't wait to find out what the answer is.

[Todd Pence]

Wow! And I thought this one was going to be a snap! Looks like I've posted a stumper instead.

[JoeZagorski]

They've all scored at least one touchdown in their pro careers.

Joe Zagorski

[Todd Pence]

Yes, that's part of it . . .

[SixtiesFan]

Scored a TD in a Playoff game?

[Todd Pence]

Yes, but what was special about each touchdown?

[oldecapecod11]

It was the only TD for their team? <=== scratch this! phooey...

[Ben]

They scored the first playoff TD in the history of their team?

[Todd Pence]

Hey! We have a winner! Great job figuring it out.