Page 4 of 5
Re: The best, and undrafted, NFL QBs that won a NC in colleg
Posted: Thu Apr 14, 2022 11:49 am
by racepug
SixtiesFan wrote:According to Wikipedia the voting had already finished before the game. Doug Flutie had a great season before the Miami game.
Well, in my defense I was focused on the Washington Huskies in 1984 - not some pint-size and (to me) no-name QB playing for a college team that I never gave any regard to.
Re: The best, and undrafted, NFL QBs that won a NC in colleg
Posted: Thu Apr 14, 2022 11:59 am
by GameBeforeTheMoney
The best NFL quarterback that was never drafted has got to be Warren Moon.
Re: The best, and undrafted, NFL QBs that won a NC in colleg
Posted: Thu Apr 14, 2022 12:03 pm
by GameBeforeTheMoney
Or you can say Kurt Warner -- forgot about him. Those are easily the two best undrafted that come to mind.
Re: The best, and undrafted, NFL QBs that won a NC in colleg
Posted: Thu Apr 14, 2022 12:03 pm
by racepug
GameBeforeTheMoney wrote:The best NFL quarterback that was never drafted has got to be Warren Moon.
Yeah. There's certainly a case to be made for him. Too bad most people in the sport at that time felt that "blacks" couldn't play quarterback.
Re: The best, and undrafted, NFL QBs that won a NC in colleg
Posted: Thu Apr 14, 2022 12:06 pm
by GameBeforeTheMoney
As far as NC, I think you'd have to go Namath still at this point.
Re: The best, and undrafted, NFL QBs that won a NC in colleg
Posted: Thu Apr 14, 2022 12:08 pm
by racepug
GameBeforeTheMoney wrote:As far as NC, I think you'd have to go Namath still at this point.
Or Montana (he'd be
my pick).
Re: The best, and undrafted, NFL QBs that won a NC in colleg
Posted: Thu Apr 14, 2022 12:09 pm
by GameBeforeTheMoney
racepug wrote:GameBeforeTheMoney wrote:The best NFL quarterback that was never drafted has got to be Warren Moon.
Yeah. There's certainly a case to be made for him. Too bad most people in the sport at that time felt that "blacks" couldn't play quarterback.
Yes.
He played his first six years in Canada and STILL retired with the 3rd most passing yards in NFL history -- behind Marino and Elway. Came within 300 yards or so of throwing for 5,000 yards in a season, twice. One of those years he missed the final game with an injury.
Re: The best, and undrafted, NFL QBs that won a NC in colleg
Posted: Thu Apr 14, 2022 12:11 pm
by GameBeforeTheMoney
racepug wrote:GameBeforeTheMoney wrote:As far as NC, I think you'd have to go Namath still at this point.
Or Montana (he'd be
my pick).
Oh, right. Absolutely. Forgot that he won a NC in college. Yes, Montana is also my pick.
Re: The best, and undrafted, NFL QBs that won a NC in colleg
Posted: Thu Apr 14, 2022 12:17 pm
by racepug
GameBeforeTheMoney wrote:racepug wrote:GameBeforeTheMoney wrote:As far as NC, I think you'd have to go Namath still at this point.
Or Montana (he'd be
my pick).
Oh, right. Absolutely. Forgot that he won a NC in college. Yes, Montana is also my pick.
Undrafted: Warren Moon or Kurt Warner (if I had to pick one I'd probably go with Warner); N.C.-winning: Montana or Namath; Heisman Trophy-winning: Roger Staubach
Re: The best, and undrafted, NFL QBs that won a NC in colleg
Posted: Thu Apr 14, 2022 1:03 pm
by racepug
Brian wolf wrote:I think Gino Torretta won a NC with Miami as well but was dreadful as a pro ...
He truly was. Somehow he ended up with my Seahawks at some point (probably because the 'hawks
still hadn't worked themselves free of the Kelly Stouffer/John Friesz/Dan McGwire/Jeff Kemp/Stan Gelbaugh/Rick Mirer [future H.o.F.ers, all -

] morass at QB that they got themselves into starting in the late '80s. . .also because, by
that time, his college head coach [Dennis Erickson] was the Seahawks' H.C.).
Somehow I remember the ONE game that Gino Torretta started for SEA - a late-season game vs. the Raiders.
He was horrible. Throwing passes (to guys in the
flat) into the ground. Missing receivers by 10 yards (wide, high - you name it). But he
somehow managed to throw for ONE touchdown in that game, and wouldn't you know it? That
one pass by Gino Torretta probably won the game for the Seahawks that day.
https://www.pro-football-reference.com/ ... 220rai.htm
My only
other memory of that game is of me thinking at the time that "if there's any justice in the world,
every single player on the field today will refuse his paycheck for the week." It was truly one of the most pitiful displays of "professional" football that I've ever seen.