Re: WRs better known for being with their 2nd or 3rd teams
Posted: Tue Apr 28, 2020 7:22 pm
Elroy Hirsch started with the Chicago Rockets of the AAFC, through the Rams and the NFL on his way to the HoF.
PFRA is a nonprofit organization dedicated to the history of professional football. Formed in 1979, PFRA members include many of the game's foremost historians and writers.
https://mail.profootballresearchers.org/forum/
https://mail.profootballresearchers.org/forum/viewtopic.php?t=5688
Maybe Mitchell, but Warfield was already an established star and the reason why it took the fourth pick in the draft for the Dolphins to get him.JuggernautJ wrote:Bobby Mitchell and Paul Warfield, both ex-Browns, come to mind.
Perhaps it's my personal prejudices (I barely recall seeing Warfield play as a Brown, I would've been 10 when he left) but I do recall (vividly) the early '70's Dolphins. Maybe that's why I think of Warfield as being "better known" in Miami.BD Sullivan wrote:Maybe Mitchell, but Warfield was already an established star and the reason why it took the fourth pick in the draft for the Dolphins to get him.JuggernautJ wrote:Bobby Mitchell and Paul Warfield, both ex-Browns, come to mind.
I think Warfield is a guy where there can be a legitimate difference of opinion as to which team he's more associated with. I think Miami myself, but I could listen to arguments for Cleveland.JuggernautJ wrote:Perhaps it's my personal prejudices (I barely recall seeing Warfield play as a Brown, I would've been 10 when he left) but I do recall (vividly) the early '70's Dolphins. Maybe that's why I think of Warfield as being "better known" in Miami.BD Sullivan wrote:Maybe Mitchell, but Warfield was already an established star and the reason why it took the fourth pick in the draft for the Dolphins to get him.JuggernautJ wrote:Bobby Mitchell and Paul Warfield, both ex-Browns, come to mind.
Was Rison ever known for being on any one particular team? I think IIRC he holds the records for most different teams to score a touchdown for. (7 I think)Teo wrote:Andre Rison
Wes Chandler
Freddie Scott
Freddie Solomon
Wallace Francis
Warfield was an all-pro with both Cleveland and Miami so I don't think he qualifies for this list. I call it a draw.conace21 wrote: I think Warfield is a guy where there can be a legitimate difference of opinion as to which team he's more associated with. I think Miami myself, but I could listen to arguments for Cleveland.
The reason why Miami Warfield gets more visibility than the (original) Cleveland version is obviously the fact that the Dolphins were a mini-dynasty where highlights are constantly being shown, whereas the Browns were "only" "a consistently solid team that won their last title in ancient times (aka pre-Super Bowl)JohnH19 wrote:Warfield was an all-pro with both Cleveland and Miami so I don't think he qualifies for this list. I call it a draw.conace21 wrote: I think Warfield is a guy where there can be a legitimate difference of opinion as to which team he's more associated with. I think Miami myself, but I could listen to arguments for Cleveland.
BD Sullivan wrote:The reason why Miami Warfield gets more visibility than the (original) Cleveland version is obviously the fact that the Dolphins were a mini-dynasty where highlights are constantly being shown, whereas the Browns were "only" "a consistently solid team that won their last title in ancient times (aka pre-Super Bowl)JohnH19 wrote:Couldn't agree more, Warfield was just as good a Brown but the Browns didn't reach the levels of the Find. Even though the Browns were very good.conace21 wrote: I think Warfield is a guy where there can be a legitimate difference of opinion as to which team he's more associated with. I think Miami myself, but I could listen to arguments for Cleveland.
Warfield was an all-pro with both Cleveland and Miami so I don't think he qualifies for this list. I call it a draw.