Are there two teams that have faced each other without playing a memorable game?

Brian wolf
Posts: 4860
Joined: Wed Nov 27, 2019 12:43 am

Re: Are there two teams that have faced each other without playing a memorable game?

Post by Brian wolf »

The Jets beat the Giants and denied them the playoffs in 1988. That Jets team had talent on offense but O'Brien ran hot and cold.
He never could get the ball to Wesley Walker enough, who had seven TDs off 26 catches but also had Toon and Shuler. Toon looked like Randy Moss but without the great speed. Losing Gastineau that year was big.
readjack
Posts: 273
Joined: Tue Jul 18, 2023 11:00 am

Re: Are there two teams that have faced each other without playing a memorable game?

Post by readjack »

saturdaysarebetter wrote: ↑Mon Nov 16, 2026 1:42 pm

So which two franchises meeting in their history, have never met in the post-season, and have not played a memorable game, a non-storied history between the two franchises if you will?
Fun! I'm going to think about this just for the Bears.

Let's remove the Packers first, since we've played a bajillion memorable games against them, including three in the playoffs. Now let's remove these teams who we played in championship games, whether NFL championships, NFC championships or the Super Bowl: Giants, Washington, Rams, Patriots, Saints, Colts.

We played the Portsmouth Spartans in the defacto '32 title game, and they became the Lions. But we've also had very memorable games against the Lions, perhaps most famously on Thanksgiving in 1980 with the Dave Williams walkoff. We've played many memorable games against the Vikings, including a playoff win. We played fewer memorable games against Tampa, but we do have a very historic game from 1979, the first game in NFL history between two Black starting quarterbacks.

We've played memorable playoff games against the Eagles, 49ers and Seahawks, and other playoff games are varying memorability against the Cowboys and Panthers. And the crosstown rivalry with the Chicago Cardinals featured some of the greatest, most intense, most notable games in franchise history. Add to that They Are Who We Thought They Were and that rivalry is a gold mine.

That's 16 teams right there, so we have 15 to go. The most memorable game off the top of my head, by how objectively, not subjectively, memorable I think they were:

* Dolphins: 1985 loss that spoiled the perfect season
* Browns: The second Mike Brown Game
* Raiders: The 1984 beatdown game
* Jaguars: The Keith Traylor Game
* KC: The 1977 thriller
* Broncos: Probably the heartbreaking Tebow game, or the crazy 2007 shootout
* Jets: 1991 overtime thriller
* Falcons: We've had a bunch of good ones, with wins and losses. The one that probably stands out to most people is Urlacher vs. Vick in '05, as well as '01.
* Bills: 1994 win that led Chicagoan Marv Levy to write a Bills fight song because he got tired of hearing "Bear Down, Chicago Bears"
* Bengals: Last year's bonkers back-and-forth game with the Loveland winner
* Titans: 2004 overtime thriller or the time Bears fans drank Nashville out of beer in 2012
* Steelers: The Bradshaw Bowl in '69, the first Soldier Field game in '71, the terribly upsetting OT loss in '95, Bus runs over Urlacher in '05
* Ravens: Crazy rain games in 2005 and 2013. Not famous but memorable.
* Texans: These have kind of been duds. The biggest tie is probably not a Bears-Texans game, but Lovie leading the Texans to the win that got us Caleb. Otherwise, I'd say the 2012 bummer.
* Chargers: Not much here. Maybe the '99 OT game.

Considering we have strong connections to the Steelers and Ravens, even if the games aren't as strong, I think the two at the bottom here are the Chargers and Texans. Since the Texans got us Caleb, I'll put the Chargers at the bottom.
Brian wolf
Posts: 4860
Joined: Wed Nov 27, 2019 12:43 am

Re: Are there two teams that have faced each other without playing a memorable game?

Post by Brian wolf »

readjack wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 5:51 pm
saturdaysarebetter wrote: ↑Mon Nov 16, 2026 1:42 pm

So which two franchises meeting in their history, have never met in the post-season, and have not played a memorable game, a non-storied history between the two franchises if you will?
Fun! I'm going to think about this just for the Bears.

Let's remove the Packers first, since we've played a bajillion memorable games against them, including three in the playoffs. Now let's remove these teams who we played in championship games, whether NFL championships, NFC championships or the Super Bowl: Giants, Washington, Rams, Patriots, Saints, Colts.

We played the Portsmouth Spartans in the defacto '32 title game, and they became the Lions. But we've also had very memorable games against the Lions, perhaps most famously on Thanksgiving in 1980 with the Dave Williams walkoff. We've played many memorable games against the Vikings, including a playoff win. We played fewer memorable games against Tampa, but we do have a very historic game from 1979, the first game in NFL history between two Black starting quarterbacks.

We've played memorable playoff games against the Eagles, 49ers and Seahawks, and other playoff games are varying memorability against the Cowboys and Panthers. And the crosstown rivalry with the Chicago Cardinals featured some of the greatest, most intense, most notable games in franchise history. Add to that They Are Who We Thought They Were and that rivalry is a gold mine.

That's 16 teams right there, so we have 15 to go. The most memorable game off the top of my head, by how objectively, not subjectively, memorable I think they were:

* Dolphins: 1985 loss that spoiled the perfect season
* Browns: The second Mike Brown Game
* Raiders: The 1984 beatdown game
* Jaguars: The Keith Traylor Game
* KC: The 1977 thriller
* Broncos: Probably the heartbreaking Tebow game, or the crazy 2007 shootout
* Jets: 1991 overtime thriller
* Falcons: We've had a bunch of good ones, with wins and losses. The one that probably stands out to most people is Urlacher vs. Vick in '05, as well as '01.
* Bills: 1994 win that led Chicagoan Marv Levy to write a Bills fight song because he got tired of hearing "Bear Down, Chicago Bears"
* Bengals: Last year's bonkers back-and-forth game with the Loveland winner
* Titans: 2004 overtime thriller or the time Bears fans drank Nashville out of beer in 2012
* Steelers: The Bradshaw Bowl in '69, the first Soldier Field game in '71, the terribly upsetting OT loss in '95, Bus runs over Urlacher in '05
* Ravens: Crazy rain games in 2005 and 2013. Not famous but memorable.
* Texans: These have kind of been duds. The biggest tie is probably not a Bears-Texans game, but Lovie leading the Texans to the win that got us Caleb. Otherwise, I'd say the 2012 bummer.
* Chargers: Not much here. Maybe the '99 OT game.

Considering we have strong connections to the Steelers and Ravens, even if the games aren't as strong, I think the two at the bottom here are the Chargers and Texans. Since the Texans got us Caleb, I'll put the Chargers at the bottom.
The Chargers and Bears had a memorable game in 1981 after the Bears were embarrased by the Lions and Eric Hipple. Buddy Ryan started implementing elements of his new 46 defense to pressure Fouts and Air Coryell into mistakes. A tough loss, but the defense would keep adding to its new style of attacking team's interior lines.

They played another tough game with the Chargers on MNF in 1984, but despite their great defense that year, Bobby Duckworth burned them on deep completions from QB Ed Luther.
readjack
Posts: 273
Joined: Tue Jul 18, 2023 11:00 am

Re: Are there two teams that have faced each other without playing a memorable game?

Post by readjack »

Thanks Brian!
JWL
Posts: 1302
Joined: Tue Mar 17, 2015 12:35 pm
Location: New Jersey

Re: Are there two teams that have faced each other without playing a memorable game?

Post by JWL »

Gary Najman wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 5:00 pm For many years I thought of the Jets vs. all the teams of the NFC East (including the Cardinals). Then I found the 1974 NFL Films highlights of the OT game at the Yale Bowl vs. the Giants. But still, I can't remember more memorable games of the Jets vs. those teams.
In 2019, the 1-7 Jets hosted the 2-7 Giants. It was agreed upon before the game that the head coach of the losing team would quit immediately after the game. Both head coaches had to bring their suitcases to the game. The Jets won 34-27. As the clock struck 0:00 Giants head coach Pat Shurmur walked out of the stadium through one of the tunnels behind an end zone with his suitcase.

This actually did not happen but it should have.
Post Reply