A few of you may have seen me refer to the period in the NFL of 1968 to 1977 as the golden age for defense in the NFL.
I should clarify that I am not saying that all of the best defenders ever are in that ten season span, though there were a lot of good ones that I’ll list below.
But I would argue that since that was the period before the Mel Blount rule, and that rule changes since have generally made it easier for quarterbacks to pass with efficiency and for offenses to score, and that because fantasy football is a thing now, I don’t think the league itself would ever want to see scores as low as they often were at that point, and thus I don’t think we’ll ever see a group of defenders that are allowed to dominate as thoroughly as defensive players from 1968-1977 did.
And to give a shoutout to the statistical accomplishments:
That period saw by my count 34 teams that allowed 14 points per game or less (I count 26 in the years afterward, and 17 across 1947-1967; roughly between the time where fewer players played both ways):
1968 Colts
1968 Cowboys
1968 Chiefs
1969 Vikings
1969 Lions
1969 Chiefs
1970 Vikings
1971 Vikings
1971 Colts
1971 Dolphins
1971 Redskins
1972 Dolphins
1972 Steelers
1973 Dolphins
1973 Vikings
1973 Raiders
1973 Rams
1973 Chiefs
1974 Rams
1974 Steelers
1974 Vikings
1974 Redskins
1975 Rams
1975 Steelers
1975 Vikings
1976 Steelers
1976 Vikings
1976 49ers
1976 Rams
1976 Cowboys
1977 Falcons
1977 Rams
1977 Broncos
1977 Redskins
By my count there are 17 teams in this span that allowed less than four yards per play for a season (there are three after 1977, and three from 1947-1967)
1968 Rams
1969 Vikings
1970 Vikings
1971 Vikings
1971 Colts
1973 Raiders
1973 Dolphins
1973 Steelers
1974 Steelers
1974 Redskins
1975 Raiders
1975 Rams
1976 Steelers
1976 Bengals
1976 49ers
1977 Cowboys
1977 Falcons
There also were 20 teams that allowed less than 14 first downs per game for a season from 1968-1977, there have been just five since, and while there were 33 such teams from 1947-1967, 14 of those teams were in the AAFC, with 19 in the NFL over 1947-1967.
1968 Jets
1968 Rams
1969 Chiefs
1969 Oilers
1969 Vikings
1969 Lions
1970 Vikings
1970 Lions
1970 Rams
1971 Colts
1971 Vikings
1972 Dolphins
1973 Rams
1973 Raiders
1973 Dolphins
1974 Rams
1975 Vikings
1976 Steelers
1976 Lions
1977 Falcons
Shoutout in particular to the 1969, 1970 and 1971 Vikings, 1971 Colts, 1973 Raiders, 1976 Steelers, and 1977 Falcons who each belong to all three exclusive clubs. (allowing 14 points per game or less, less than 4 yards per play and less than 14 first downs per game)
And lastly the players themselves:
By my count there are 53 defensive players who made the Pro Football Hall of Fame who played at least one season from 1968 to 1977, with 20 of them making the NFL’s 100th Anniversary All Time Team.
*Played all ten years of the golden age (13 total)
-x made 100th Anniversary All Time Team (20 total out of 39 defensive players on the team)
And I should note that the years in parentheses are the years between 1968 and 1977 in which they played. These numbers are admittedly inflated by the players who were at one of the tail ends, but by my count 41 of the Hall of Famers played at least four seasons in the range.
Defensive Backs (18):
Dick LeBeau (1968-1972)
Willie Wood (1968-1971)
Johnny Robinson (1968-1971)
Larry Wilson (1968-1972)-x
Herb Adderley (1968-1972)
Jimmy Johnson (1968-1976)
*Willie Brown (1968-1977)-x
*Mel Renfro (1968-1977)
*Paul Krause (1968-1977)
*Emmitt Thomas (1968-1977)
*Lem Barney (1968-1977)
*Ken Houston (1968-1977)-x
Roger Wherli (1969-1977)
Ken Riley (1969-1977)
Cliff Harris (1970-1977)
Mel Blount (1970-1977)-x
Donnie Shell (1974-1977)
Mike Haynes (1976-1977)-x
Defensive Ends (9):
Doug Atkins (1968-1969)-x
Willie Davis (1968-1969)
Deacon Jones (1968-1974)-x
*Carl Eller (1968-1977)
*Claude Humphrey (1968-1977)
*Elvin Bethea (1968-1977)
Jack Youngblood (1971-1977)
Fred Dean (1975-1977)
Lee Roy Selmon (1976-1977)-x
Defensive Tackles (10):
Henry Jordan (1968-1969)
Alex Karras (1968-1970)
Bob Lilly (1968-1974)-x
Merlin Olsen (1968-1976)-x
Buck Buchanan (1968-1975)-x
*Alan Page (1968-1977)-x
*Curley Culp (1968-1977)
Joe Greene (1969-1977)-x
Randy White (1975-1977)-x
Joe Klecko (1977)
Linebackers (16):
Sam Huff (1968-1969)
Ray Nitschke (1968-1972)
Chuck Howley (1968-1973)
Nick Buoniconti (1968-1976)
Bobby Bell (1968-1974)-x
Dave Robinson (1968-1974)
Dave Wilcox (1968-1974)
Dick Butkus (1968-1973)-x
*Chris Hanburger (1968-1977)
*Willie Lanier (1968-1977)-x
Ted Hendricks (1969-1977)-x
Jack Ham (1971-1977)-x
Randy Gradishar (1974-1977)
Jack Lambert (1974-1977)-x
Robert Brazille (1975-1977)
Harry Carson (1976-1977)
There are also by my count 37 defensive players who played at least one season in this span that are in the Hall of Very Good, with 26 such players playing in at least four seasons in the span:
Defensive Ends (12):
Lyle Alzado (1971-1977)
*Coy Bacon (1968-1977)
Ken Gray (1968-1970)
*L.C. Greenwood (1968-1977)
Rich Jackson (1968-1972)
Too Tall Jones (1974-1977)
Jim Katcavage (1968)
*Jim Marshall (1968-1977)
Harvey Martin (1973-1977)
Jerry Mays (1968-1970)
*Ron McDole (1968-1977)
Bill Stanfill (1969-1976)
Defensive Tackles (2):
Roger Brown (1968-1969)
Tom Sestak (1968)
Defensive Backs (13):
*Dick Anderson (1968-1977)
Erich Barnes (1968-1971)
Bobby Boyd (1968)
Nolan Cromwell (1977)
*Pat Fischer (1968-1977)
Dave Grayson (1968-1970)
Cornell Green (1968-1974)
Lester Hayes (1977)
Eddie Meador (1968-1970)
Lemar Parrish (1970-1977)
Richie Petitbon (1968-1972)
Jake Scott (1970-1977)
Louis Wright (1975-1977)
Linebackers (10):
Maxie Baughan (1968-1970, 1974)
Bill Bergey (1969-1977)
Matt Blair (1974-1977)
*Mike Curtis (1968-1977)
Larry Grantham (1968-1972)
Lee Roy Jordan (1968-1976)
Tommy Nobis (1968-1976)
Isiah Robertson (1971-1977)
Andy Russell (1968-1976)
Mike Stratton (1968-1973)
A few notes on the “Golden Age” of Defense (1968-1977)
-
SeahawkFever
- Posts: 996
- Joined: Mon Jan 08, 2024 4:18 am
A few notes on the “Golden Age” of Defense (1968-1977)
Last edited by SeahawkFever on Fri Nov 13, 2026 12:53 pm, edited 2 times in total.
-
Brian wolf
- Posts: 4860
- Joined: Wed Nov 27, 2019 12:43 am
Re: A few notes on the “Golden Age” of Defense (1968-1977)
Great list of all those players. Many on that HOVG list should be in the HOF but you cant put in everybody ...
Still, I would have substituted certain HOVG players over some ones who actually made the HOF, like ...
Jake Scott over Paul Krause ... Many might not agree, with Krause's ability to intercept the ball, but I believe Scott had more impact overrall and in postseason. The Dolphins didnt have the dominant pass rush that would have led to errant throws like the Vikings.
Dick Anderson over Cliff Harris ... I am a huge Cowboys fan of that era and knew how tough Harris was, but I felt Anderson at his peak was the better player and like Scott, had more impact in postseason. Had Anderson not been injured from 1975-77, he would have made the Hall a while back.
Harvey Martin over Elvin Bethea ... both were great players but ironically, Bethea was better for the Oilers when they were a terrible team. Once the team upgraded the players around him, Bethea struggled more but it could have been through other factors like injuries or switching to a 34 defense. Martin did have White beside him, but was a pure pass rusher who still has the most unofficial sacks in postseason history.
Bill Bergey over Harry Carson ... both great inside linebackers but I felt Carson benefitted from the talent around him late in his career, while Bergey gets somewhat downgraded for switching teams. Bergey wasnt as talented as Carson but was slightly more important for his teams.
Maxie Baughan over Dave Robinson ... both excellent outside linebackers but while Baughan got recently rejected by HOF voters after being endorsed by the Senior Committee itself, Robinson benefitted from the "dominant" team effect, where a great team simply has/had too many players elected. He didnt have to go through voter fatigue like LC Greenwood--another endorsed player from the Senior Committee, rejected by voters--went through for the Steelers.
Lemar Parrish over Ken Riley ... I have no problem with Riley's election, as he was a great ballhawk who played his entire career in Cincinatti but Parrish was the better overrall player, who like Bill Bergey, is downgraded for leaving the Bengals for another team.
He should have gotten elected for his special teams and non-offensive TDs alone, where he had far more career impact as an overrall player than a Devin Hester, but continues to wait in the senior abyss.
Bobby Boyd over Dick LeBeau ... LeBeau was a tough, ball hawking corner for the Lions, but really got elected due to his great coaching as well, but Boyd was just as tough and as good as LeBeau as a player, who had more postseason impact due to being on better Colts teams.
Boyd wasnt the coach that LeBeau was but helped bring in the Cover-2 defense to pro football after it evolved from the famous Baltimore zone defense, that Boyd ran well despite not being as physically talented as other cornerbacks. What hurts Boyd's election to the HOF were the two championship games, where he was exposed by Gary Collins of Cleveland and Don Maynard of the Jets but those two were great players with Collins having a size advantage over Boyd, while Maynard had the speed advantage.
Despite the Colts rotating their coverage towards Maynard's side in SB III, Boyd still held him without a catch. In the NFL championship revenge win over the Browns, Boyd helped neutralize Collins and the great Paul Warfield as well. He deserves HOF election.
Still, I would have substituted certain HOVG players over some ones who actually made the HOF, like ...
Jake Scott over Paul Krause ... Many might not agree, with Krause's ability to intercept the ball, but I believe Scott had more impact overrall and in postseason. The Dolphins didnt have the dominant pass rush that would have led to errant throws like the Vikings.
Dick Anderson over Cliff Harris ... I am a huge Cowboys fan of that era and knew how tough Harris was, but I felt Anderson at his peak was the better player and like Scott, had more impact in postseason. Had Anderson not been injured from 1975-77, he would have made the Hall a while back.
Harvey Martin over Elvin Bethea ... both were great players but ironically, Bethea was better for the Oilers when they were a terrible team. Once the team upgraded the players around him, Bethea struggled more but it could have been through other factors like injuries or switching to a 34 defense. Martin did have White beside him, but was a pure pass rusher who still has the most unofficial sacks in postseason history.
Bill Bergey over Harry Carson ... both great inside linebackers but I felt Carson benefitted from the talent around him late in his career, while Bergey gets somewhat downgraded for switching teams. Bergey wasnt as talented as Carson but was slightly more important for his teams.
Maxie Baughan over Dave Robinson ... both excellent outside linebackers but while Baughan got recently rejected by HOF voters after being endorsed by the Senior Committee itself, Robinson benefitted from the "dominant" team effect, where a great team simply has/had too many players elected. He didnt have to go through voter fatigue like LC Greenwood--another endorsed player from the Senior Committee, rejected by voters--went through for the Steelers.
Lemar Parrish over Ken Riley ... I have no problem with Riley's election, as he was a great ballhawk who played his entire career in Cincinatti but Parrish was the better overrall player, who like Bill Bergey, is downgraded for leaving the Bengals for another team.
He should have gotten elected for his special teams and non-offensive TDs alone, where he had far more career impact as an overrall player than a Devin Hester, but continues to wait in the senior abyss.
Bobby Boyd over Dick LeBeau ... LeBeau was a tough, ball hawking corner for the Lions, but really got elected due to his great coaching as well, but Boyd was just as tough and as good as LeBeau as a player, who had more postseason impact due to being on better Colts teams.
Boyd wasnt the coach that LeBeau was but helped bring in the Cover-2 defense to pro football after it evolved from the famous Baltimore zone defense, that Boyd ran well despite not being as physically talented as other cornerbacks. What hurts Boyd's election to the HOF were the two championship games, where he was exposed by Gary Collins of Cleveland and Don Maynard of the Jets but those two were great players with Collins having a size advantage over Boyd, while Maynard had the speed advantage.
Despite the Colts rotating their coverage towards Maynard's side in SB III, Boyd still held him without a catch. In the NFL championship revenge win over the Browns, Boyd helped neutralize Collins and the great Paul Warfield as well. He deserves HOF election.
-
SeahawkFever
- Posts: 996
- Joined: Mon Jan 08, 2024 4:18 am
Re: A few notes on the “Golden Age” of Defense (1968-1977)
I could see a few of those, in particular Harvey Martin, Jake Scott and Dick Anderson deserve another look for Canton in my opinion.Brian wolf wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 12:17 pm Great list of all those players. Many on that HOVG list should be in the HOF but you cant put in everybody ...
Still, I would have substituted certain HOVG players over some ones who actually made the HOF, like ...
Jake Scott over Paul Krause ... Many might not agree, with Krause's ability to intercept the ball, but I believe Scott had more impact overrall and in postseason. The Dolphins didnt have the dominant pass rush that would have led to errant throws like the Vikings.
Dick Anderson over Cliff Harris ... I am a huge Cowboys fan of that era and knew how tough Harris was, but I felt Anderson at his peak was the better player and like Scott, had more impact in postseason. Had Anderson not been injured from 1975-77, he would have made the Hall a while back.
Harvey Martin over Elvin Bethea ... both were great players but ironically, Bethea was better for the Oilers when they were a terrible team. Once the team upgraded the players around him, Bethea struggled more but it could have been through other factors like injuries or switching to a 34 defense. Martin did have White beside him, but was a pure pass rusher who still has the most unofficial sacks in postseason history.
Bill Bergey over Harry Carson ... both great inside linebackers but I felt Carson benefitted from the talent around him late in his career, while Bergey gets somewhat downgraded for switching teams. Bergey wasnt as talented as Carson but was slightly more important for his teams.
Maxie Baughan over Dave Robinson ... both excellent outside linebackers but while Baughan got recently rejected by HOF voters after being endorsed by the Senior Committee itself, Robinson benefitted from the "dominant" team effect, where a great team simply has/had too many players elected. He didnt have to go through voter fatigue like LC Greenwood--another endorsed player from the Senior Committee, rejected by voters--went through for the Steelers.
Lemar Parrish over Ken Riley ... I have no problem with Riley's election, as he was a great ballhawk who played his entire career in Cincinatti but Parrish was the better overrall player, who like Bill Bergey, is downgraded for leaving the Bengals for another team.
He should have gotten elected for his special teams and non-offensive TDs alone, where he had far more career impact as an overrall player than a Devin Hester, but continues to wait in the senior abyss.
There is also one player who deserves an honorable mention who isn’t Hall of Very Good but should be in my opinion:
The defensive tackle Diron Talbert who played for the Rams from 1967-1970, and for the Redskins from 1971-1980. At first glance he has only one pro bowl and no all pros to his name (on the great 1974 Redskins team that made two of the lists I believe).
But consider the following: He is unofficially credited with 84.5 sacks, and 71.5 over his eight best seasons combined (that’s only one fewer than Bob Lilly, and 4.5 more than Merlin Olsen), and while he doesn’t have many accolades individually, one could argue that he had the misfortune of being overshadowed during a time where not only every player I mentioned was playing, but when the defensive tackle position was absolutely stacked.
Consider that Bob Lilly, Randy White, Alan Page, Merlin Olsen, Joe Greene, and Buck Buchanan are all listed as playing defensive tackle in this time for their teams and are listed on the 100th Anniversary All Time Team (unless I’m forgetting something), and all of them overlapped with his career (with Lilly being replaced by White of course).
If the competition wasn’t that stacked at that time, Talbert (who has four seasons of double digit sacks in a 14 game season as a defensive tackle) is getting more accolades.
That sounds like Hall of Very Good to me.
-
Brian wolf
- Posts: 4860
- Joined: Wed Nov 27, 2019 12:43 am
Re: A few notes on the “Golden Age” of Defense (1968-1977)
Great call SeahawkFever ... Talbert deserves mention. I kept revising my list. I still dont see why OT Jon Kolb of the Steelers hasnt made the HOVG? His accolades are so light, he might be the most underrated player in NFL history. Though I feel Harvey Martin should get elected to the HOF, Kolb blocked him effectively in both SB games against Dallas.
Not to nitpick but Ken Gray made the HOVG as an offensive guard.
Not to nitpick but Ken Gray made the HOVG as an offensive guard.