Rating the Super Bowl Champions of the 1970s

SeahawkFever
Posts: 996
Joined: Mon Jan 08, 2024 4:18 am

Re: Rating the Super Bowl Champions of the 1970s

Post by SeahawkFever »

PaulPFHOF wrote: ↑Mon Oct 05, 2026 4:03 pm 1. 1978 Pittsburgh Steelers
2. 1972 Miami Dolphins
3. 1975 Pittsburgh Steelers
4. 1971 Dallas Cowboys
5. 1977 Dallas Cowboys
6. 1979 Pittsburgh Steelers
7. 1973 Miami Dolphins
8. 1974 Pittsburgh Steelers
9. 1976 Oakland Raiders
10. 1970 Baltimore Colts
Why are the 76 Raiders ninth of these ten in your book?
User avatar
74_75_78_79_
Posts: 2924
Joined: Sat Oct 11, 2014 1:25 pm

Re: Rating the Super Bowl Champions of the 1970s

Post by 74_75_78_79_ »

1) ’75 Steelers
2) ’78 Steelers
3) ’72 Dolphins
4) ’73 Dolphins
5) ’71 Cowboys
6) ’76 Raiders
7) ’79 Steelers
8) ’77 Cowboys
9) ’74 Steelers
10) ’70 Colts
PaulPFHOF
Posts: 100
Joined: Mon Jun 08, 2026 2:15 pm

Re: Rating the Super Bowl Champions of the 1970s

Post by PaulPFHOF »

SeahawkFever wrote: ↑Mon Oct 05, 2026 4:35 pm
PaulPFHOF wrote: ↑Mon Oct 05, 2026 4:03 pm 1. 1978 Pittsburgh Steelers
2. 1972 Miami Dolphins
3. 1975 Pittsburgh Steelers
4. 1971 Dallas Cowboys
5. 1977 Dallas Cowboys
6. 1979 Pittsburgh Steelers
7. 1973 Miami Dolphins
8. 1974 Pittsburgh Steelers
9. 1976 Oakland Raiders
10. 1970 Baltimore Colts
Why are the 76 Raiders ninth of these ten in your book?
Its all subjective and one could make case for moving them up-but looking at those teams, those playoffs and SBs, I just don't think they were the complete team across the starting roster as those above them. Maybe they move up a few slots but my top 8 is pretty solid.
To me the other teams had better QBs/RBs/WRs and better overall complete defenses, Raiders were strong on OL and LB/DB but the repeat SB winners of Miami, Dallas, and Pittsburg had better QB/WR/RBs and more talent at DL and through out the defenses. Stabler was a good QB but in my view somewhat overrated, especially in regards to his era QBs, one could make debate he was better than Griese but across the starters those Miami teams were better where as the Steelers and Cowboys have more PFHOFers.
User avatar
74_75_78_79_
Posts: 2924
Joined: Sat Oct 11, 2014 1:25 pm

Re: Rating the Super Bowl Champions of the 1970s

Post by 74_75_78_79_ »

PaulPFHOF wrote: ↑Tue Oct 06, 2026 2:46 pm
SeahawkFever wrote: ↑Mon Oct 05, 2026 4:35 pm
PaulPFHOF wrote: ↑Mon Oct 05, 2026 4:03 pm 1. 1978 Pittsburgh Steelers
2. 1972 Miami Dolphins
3. 1975 Pittsburgh Steelers
4. 1971 Dallas Cowboys
5. 1977 Dallas Cowboys
6. 1979 Pittsburgh Steelers
7. 1973 Miami Dolphins
8. 1974 Pittsburgh Steelers
9. 1976 Oakland Raiders
10. 1970 Baltimore Colts
Why are the 76 Raiders ninth of these ten in your book?
Its all subjective and one could make case for moving them up-but looking at those teams, those playoffs and SBs, I just don't think they were the complete team across the starting roster as those above them. Maybe they move up a few slots but my top 8 is pretty solid.
To me the other teams had better QBs/RBs/WRs and better overall complete defenses, Raiders were strong on OL and LB/DB but the repeat SB winners of Miami, Dallas, and Pittsburg had better QB/WR/RBs and more talent at DL and through out the defenses. Stabler was a good QB but in my view somewhat overrated, especially in regards to his era QBs, one could make debate he was better than Griese but across the starters those Miami teams were better where as the Steelers and Cowboys have more PFHOFers.
I, myself, could probably place the Raiders higher (than #6) on my own list. Just a little (a little) bit lesser than their actual 13-1 record with me. Maybe a 12, or 11-win, team in disguise which is really no big deal; barely worth even bringing up. Still a true great SB-champ.

Its not the Steelers not having Franco & Rocky in the AFCCG. I as a Steeler-fan have always been real open with the Raiders still winning anyway - never had it in Gospel, the Steelers winning had #32 & #20 been present. The bigger thing with me is they actually allowing the Pats to beat them, 48-17, in Wk#4 only to avenge things in the divisional round, at home, by controversial measure. This while not having that statistically great of defense - especially against the run, and not the greatest run-game stat-wise either.

But off-paper matters as well and they were Madden's best '70s team thus the team that finally should have finished-the-job if only one Raiders team that decade were to. Although Minny was yet another two years older than their last SB-appearance, beating them the way they did is still a feat worth praising along with they not only beating, but blasting, a Cincy team late that needed to win to get in while Oakland could have easily coasted/'letting' the Bengals win so the 'Burgh could be eliminated. They tore it up anyway which should say a lot with many of us.
Post Reply