If McMahon wasn't hurt in 1986, do the Bears repeat as Super Bowl champions?

Post Reply
saturdaysarebetter
Posts: 113
Joined: Thu Oct 09, 2025 7:43 pm

If McMahon wasn't hurt in 1986, do the Bears repeat as Super Bowl champions?

Post by saturdaysarebetter »

If Jim McMahon wasn't intentionally hurt by a late, illegal throw down, by Green Bay's Charles Martin in week 12 of the 1986 season, would the Bears have repeated as Super Bowl champs?
SeahawkFever
Posts: 996
Joined: Mon Jan 08, 2024 4:18 am

Re: If McMahon wasn't hurt in 1986, do the Bears repeat as Super Bowl champions?

Post by SeahawkFever »

I’d lean towards no.

On one hand the 1986 Bears defense arguably played even better than 85 did (at least in the regular season), but on the other hand, McMahon’s passing stats were worse even before that injury that season, and the running game wasn’t quite as good as the prior year (both Walter Payton and Matt Suhey had less yardage on fewer yards per carry in 1986 than they did in 1985).

The 1986 Bears did something we might never see again: They had the best record in the NFL at 14-2 while simultaneously being the worst team at passing the football by passer rating (both by raw total and when adjusting for opponent quality)
Sonny9
Posts: 422
Joined: Sun Oct 01, 2017 5:57 pm

Re: If McMahon wasn't hurt in 1986, do the Bears repeat as Super Bowl champions?

Post by Sonny9 »

They had a problem with turnovers that year. 16 more than '85, and the offense scored ~100 less points
Turnover differential +1 after the Packer game, -1 the last 4 games. Even for the year. 1985 +23

Even though McMahon was sacked half as often in '86 his completion % went from 57 to 51. TDs to Ints 15-11 vs 5-8

Healthy for the entire year, yes they take it. Everything is the same except he is not hurt for the playoffs, no they don't
Brian wolf
Posts: 4860
Joined: Wed Nov 27, 2019 12:43 am

Re: If McMahon wasn't hurt in 1986, do the Bears repeat as Super Bowl champions?

Post by Brian wolf »

I say No ... the Giants year. The Bears defense wasnt the same without Ryan. Washington easily exposed them.
Post Reply