Matthew Stafford: HOVG, or HOF?

Discuss candidates for the Pro Football Hall of Fame and the PFRA's Hall of Very Good
Brian wolf
Posts: 4443
Joined: Wed Nov 27, 2019 12:43 am

Re: Matthew Stafford: HOVG, or HOF?

Post by Brian wolf »

Stafford deserves credit for helping goad Woolen into that ridiculous penalty yesterday as well. Like Namath getting pissed at George Atkinson for running his mouth in the 1968 AFL Championship game, Stafford immediately picked on Woolen for the TD pass. Namath went after Atkinson on a bomb to Maynard that helped decide that game.

When the Rams got the ball back--some on here felt they should have gone for two after the TD--I felt for certain that they would score another one. On 4th down they went for it and came up short ... should they have kicked the FG?

I will admit, with their momentum, they probably should have went for two after Stafford burned Woolen on the TD but McVay probably felt it was too early to chase points? Who would have thought they wouldnt score in the 4th quarter?
readjack
Posts: 192
Joined: Tue Jul 18, 2023 11:00 am

Re: Matthew Stafford: HOVG, or HOF?

Post by readjack »

I definitely thought they should have taken the field goal. You do that and it's a one-point game and you add four minutes to the clock. But that doesn't seem to be the nature of the league right now, so I'm more forgiving.
Brian wolf
Posts: 4443
Joined: Wed Nov 27, 2019 12:43 am

Re: Matthew Stafford: HOVG, or HOF?

Post by Brian wolf »

Its doubtful to me that Stafford will retire. If I am not mistaken, the last NFL player to win MVP and retire is Jim Brown. I think he will be back because of Sean McVay ...

Admittedly though, you could see why Stafford could think about it. He has to be extremely frustrated with his team's last three postseason losses.

--The Rams couldnt really stop Detroit in the 2023/24 playoff, yet Stafford and the Rams offense had their chance to win the game.
On 3rd and 4 at the Detroit 34 yard line, their tackle was called for holding with over 4 minutes left. Stafford threw incomplete but they had to punt from the 44 yrd line. The Lions ran out the clock to win 24-23.

--They beat Darnold and the 14-3 Vikings but once again, had a bad defensive game against Barkley for Philly. Still, Stafford had a chance to win that game in the final 1:20 seconds at the Philly 23 yrd line but a sack by Jalen Carter, forced an incompletion on 4th down.

--Then the failed 4th down from the Seahawks 6 yrd line yesterday. Once again, like the Lions loss, the Seahawks ran out the last four minutes of the clock. Losses that any player would agonize over.

If McVay could get a talented CB in the draft and free agency(Woolen? Who had the boneheaded penalty?) This team can get back quickly.
JuggernautJ
Posts: 1575
Joined: Sat Oct 11, 2014 7:14 pm
Location: NinerLand, Ca.

Re: Matthew Stafford: HOVG, or HOF?

Post by JuggernautJ »

Stafford is set to make $56 million next season.

1. I kind of doubt he'll walk away from that.

2. These kind of salaries cripple teams.
Teams would be a lot more balanced/better if they didn't have to carry such outlandish salaries (and so would many companies).
There's a reason why teams with QBs "still on their rookie contracts" have done so well over the past decade(s).

If Stafford really wanted another ring maybe he could buy the team a defensive player or two.
(Not that I blame Stafford... it is the state of the game today.)

On the original topic:
Do we think this season helped or hurt Stafford's reputation and/or shot at the HoF?
Brian wolf
Posts: 4443
Joined: Wed Nov 27, 2019 12:43 am

Re: Matthew Stafford: HOVG, or HOF?

Post by Brian wolf »

It definitely helped, because the team met expectations making the NFC Championship game. He will also probably be MVP.
Post Reply