Eli, 2013

[JameisBrownston]

Somehow, I don't have a strong memory of this shockingly horrible season, coming straight off his 2nd ring. Can someone remind me what caused him to play so abominably? This has to be the worst performance by a notable modern-era QB, besides 2015 Peyton, and far less explicable.

[Bob Gill]

The Giants won the second Super Bowl with Manning at the end of the 2011 season, so 2013 was two years later. In 2012 he had one of his better seasons.