Reaser, thanks for asking. I've actually been on board with the idea that AP isn't the only game in town re all-pro teams for a good while now. Because I got flack from several folks at other websites, I used to show Darrell Green's profile as 4(1 AP)/7/90s, but I don't even do that these days. I've also challenged people with AP-only thinking at these other sites (not much need to do so here) for a good while.Reaser wrote:Ah, you're using the other major selectors now for your 'profiles'? Good to see it's not "AP Only" anymore ... or at least this is the first time I've noticed the change.bachslunch wrote:I have Darrell Green as 4/7/90s (86-87 NEA, 90 PFWkly, 91 consensus) ...
The only team I don't give equal weight to is Sporting News up to ca. 1980 since it's analogous to a lumped-together group of all-conference teams. Until I see a good reason to discount any others, I'm giving the rest equal weight.