Philip Rivers retired.

[TanksAndSpartans]

HOF?

[Brian wolf]

Good to great career ... not enough postseason success. I ay No

[TanksAndSpartans]

I would vote no as well. No championships and 2 seasons with postseason honors. I'd be interested to hear the argument for anyone voting yes.

[Brian wolf]

In 15 years as a starter, he averaged nearly 9 wins per year. His only postseason wins were in the wild card round except for one divisional win. His career in the NFL, is very similiar to Warren Moon.

P Manning
E Manning
Brees
Rothlisberger
Ryan
Rodgers
Brady
Wilson - later
Mahomes - later

Anderson
Simms
McNabb

I rank these players ahead of Rivers. Will he somehow get voted in over some of them ?

[Jay Z]

Rivers does well on the HOF monitor because he played for a long time, didn't get hurt, and has good stats.

I mentioned on the Rothlisberger thread that his numbers in two minute situations are bad. He was bad again in his playoff loss. Enough for me to vote no.

[rewing84]

I'd take anderson over rivers

[Brian wolf]

Robert do you think Rivers deserves to make the HOF ?

[rewing84]

I'll put it this way Anderson has the better post season track record rivers has the stats for regular season but not a good postseason record in short no on rivers

[Brian wolf]

To be honest, come July, Rivers may want to come back but who might get him ?

If Stafford could win a SB with the Rams, it could restart talks of HOF but he needs to win more games the rest of his career as well, in my view.

[sluggermatt15]

I'd take anderson over rivers

Me too.

Anderson won an MVP, was the OPOY, and made an all-pro team. Also won close to 90 games.