Longtime starters with no Pro Bowl/All-Pro/All-Conference

[paulksandiego]

Sam Davis, OG, Pittsburgh Steelers

[7DnBrnc53]

Brian Habib, OG (with Vikings, Broncos, and Seahawks from 88-99)
Phillip Daniels, DE (with Seahawks, Bears, and Redskins from 96-10)
Freddie Jones, TE (with Chargers and Cardinals from 97-04)

[DukeSlater]

Simon Fletcher.

[Sonny9]

Mike Bass
In seven seasons with the Redskins, Bass had 30 interceptions returning three for touchdowns. He also recovered six fumbles and gave up only eight touchdown passes in his NFL career.

I've always wondered if the bolded part is true.

[sheajets]

Bobby Engram

14 year career. 650 receptions for 7,751 yards

[conace21]

Two other members of the 1996 WR draft class are in the same boat: Amani Toomer and Eddie Kennison (each played 13 seasons, started for 10 and 9 seasons, respectively.)

[ChrisBabcock]

I am actually kind of surprised Amani Toomer never played in a Pro Bowl. Same with Bobby Engram who was mentioned earlier.

[rebelx24]

Somebody mentioned Jeff Bostic, but he doesn't belong here. He had a Pro Bowl and All-Pro in '83.

Two guys who do, though: Toomer's colleague from SB XLII, Plaxico Burress, and Green Bay tackle Mark Tauscher, who I remember being praised for his play by many writers, but somehow failed to ever receive accolades.

Santonio Holmes kind of counts, I guess, depending upon how long "longtime" is.

[sluggermatt15]

There are a good number of Steelers:

Dan Kreider, fullback
Roger Duffy, center
Jerame Tuman, tight end
Kimo von Oelhoffen, defensive end
Keydrick Vincent, guard
Earl Holmes, linebacker
Dewayne Washington, cornerback
Josh Miller, punter
John Jackson, tackle
Brentson Buckner, defensive tackle

[Ronfitch]

Ken Ruettgers, T, Packers - 140 starts/156 games played over 12 seasons
Ron Hallstrom, G Packers - 132 starts/174 games played over 12 seasons