Top-3-QB trio for each franchise and who's #1?

[74_75_78_79_]

As for picking #1, this is strictly how each QB played while they were with the particular franchise at-hand, not overall career if playing with multiple teams (ex. Bobby Layne strictly as a Lion, or strictly as a Steeler). Is Brodie/Montana/Young #1? Or is it Starr/Favre/Rodgers? How about Baugh/Jurgensen/Theismann? Staubach/Aikman/Romo? I guess Luck's newness (though recently surpassing Bert Jones) holds down he, Unitas, and Peyton from top-spot consideration.

[JeffreyMiller]

Starr Favre Rodgers

[74_75_78_79_]

I guess for KC it would actually be...Dawson, Trent Green, and (despite just two years onboard)...Joe Cool himself?

Back to Colts...when I said that Andrew Luck already surpassed Bert Jones, I guess I should have said Earl Morrall. In fact, shouldn't Jim Harbaugh be placed above Jones as well?

McMahon and Cutler alongside Sid, I suppose?

Of course not counting relatively recent expansion teams, what would some of the weakest top-3 trios be?

[Ronfitch]

Starr Favre Rodgers

John's book takes a nice look at those three in parring down to a 53-player roster from the 1,261 who have played for Green Bay since 1950 (plus Don Hutson):

http://www.abebooks.com/9781514758595/G ... 758598/plp

[ChrisBabcock]

Of course not counting relatively recent expansion teams, what would some of the weakest top-3 trios be?

Tampa Bay.... Doug Williams and uhh... Trent Dilfer? Jeff Garcia?

[JohnH19]

Tarkenton, Culpepper, Kramer. There were also a bunch of short term guys who played very well in purple; Kapp, Wilson, Moon, Johnson, Cunningham, George and Favre.

[Todd Pence]

Of course not counting relatively recent expansion teams, what would some of the weakest top-3 trios be?

Ravens: Flacco, Testaverde, and . . . Kyle Boller!!

[rhickok1109]

Of course not counting relatively recent expansion teams, what would some of the weakest top-3 trios be?

Ravens: Flacco, Testaverde, and . . . Kyle Boller!!

No Dilfer? He did "win a Super Bowl," as some would put it.

[JeffreyMiller]

Kemp Ferguson Kelly

[JohnH19]

Kemp Ferguson Kelly

In the order of Kelly, Kemp, Ferguson, I assume?