wEirD player for player trades

[MatthewToy]

How about when Duane Thomas and a couple other players got traded to New England for Carl Garrett and their 1972 1st round pick? A week later it was voided by Pete Rozelle and Thomas and Garrett got sent back to their original teams.

[Todd Pence]

"Jesus Christ! What the Hell kind of a trade is that? A tight end for a tight end?"

Tom Beer reacting to his 1970 trade to the Patriots for Jim Whalen.

[Ronfitch]

Not a single trade, but (to me) an interesting series of trades. from the chart in John Maxymuk's "Packers by the Numbers" is this:

1951- Packers trade Dan Orlich to the Browns for Walt Micheals
1951 - Packers trade Bob Gain and a draft choice (who the Browns use to pick Zeke Costa) to Browns for Dan Orlich, Ace Loomis, Dom Moselle and Don Schroll
1952 - Packers trade Walt Micheals to the Browns for Dick Logan, Forest Chubby Grigg and Zeke Costa
1952- Packers trade Ace Loomis to the Browns for Tony Adamle and Don Phelps

[Todd Pence]

I know it was not a strict player-for-player scenario but the entire "Vikings trade away Tarkenton/Vikings trade to get Tarkenton back" episode(s) were rather unusual.

The Vikings also later managed to re-acquire two other quarterbacks they had previously traded away, Bob Berry and Bob Lee. Bud Grant didn't trade QBs, he loaned them.

[Ronfitch]

I know it was not a strict player-for-player scenario but the entire "Vikings trade away Tarkenton/Vikings trade to get Tarkenton back" episode(s) were rather unusual.

The Vikings also later managed to re-acquire two other quarterbacks they had previously traded away, Bob Berry and Bob Lee. Bud Grant didn't trade QBs, he loaned them.

Wonder if he required a security deposit.

[Gary Najman]

Coy Bacon had a couple of trades for Pro Bowlers (past or future): in 1972 from Los Angeles to San Diego (for John Hadl), and in 1976 from San Diego to Cincinnati (for Charlie Joiner). Then in 1978 he was traded (along with Lemar Parrish) to Washington for a 1st round draft pick.

[JWL]

How about when Duane Thomas and a couple other players got traded to New England for Carl Garrett and their 1972 1st round pick? A week later it was voided by Pete Rozelle and Thomas and Garrett got sent back to their original teams.

Another trade that was voided was Lee Suggs for Derrick Strait in the summer of 2006. Curtis Martin hadn't yet retired and the Jets wanted to upgrade the running back position. Suggs failed his physical and was sent back to Cleveland.

[Mark]

Earnest Byner and for Mike Oliphant was weird in that it was so lopsided. [I'm assuming my memory is correct that it was one player for one player]

[BD Sullivan]

Earnest Byner and for Mike Oliphant was weird in that it was so lopsided. [I'm assuming my memory is correct that it was one player for one player]

The Browns were so desperate to get rid of Byner since he was a Schottenheimer favorite that they took this miserable deal.

[Jay Z]

Other players were involved, but in 1972 the Saints and Jets swapped punters, Julian Fagan for Steve O'Neal. A couple of years earlier, the Jets traded Jim Turner to the Broncos for their kicker, Bobby Howfield.