Professional Football Researchers Association Forum

"We can spend our energy fighting the change, or we can spend it adapting to it. I’d rather we focus on succeeding under the new rules."

Brian wolf wrote: ↑Wed Sep 09, 2026 9:21 pm I dunno Paul ... the BRP in 2020 disappointed themselves. Hopefully, another panel will do much better for this hypothetical class?

You've been telling me this exact same story for six years. Nothing about the past is going to change time to move on

In terms of Buddy Parker Brian : "A quantitative analysis of Buddy Parker's career reveals a coach who extracted short-term value from existing assets rather than generating sustainable franchise growth. When evaluating his full body of work beyond the inherited Detroit championships, his struc...

Researched properly so that the best candidates get in the hall and not just random selections

id definitely be in favor of a pre 60's players induction by the hall of fame if it was done properly and with some transparency involved

Brian wolf wrote: ↑Wed Feb 11, 2026 2:39 pm Nobis was a great player but most of his reputation was from the 60s All-Decade team for 67-69. Wasnt the same after early 70s injury.

Would Maxie Baughan have been a better choice brian

Here’s my list of the most baffling All Decade choices please note I didn’t include anyone not already in the Pro Football Hall of Fame 1920s Hunk Anderson-only played four seasons and had only one All Pro 1930s Cecil Isbell-only played two seasons in the 1930s Gaynell Tinsley-also played only two ...

Agreed that sheet you mention proved nothing definitive if im correct

100% agreed him not getting the mvp in super bowl 19 after his three touchdown performance hurt him in the long run


Adam i would also be interested in a list of your top seniors not in canton

SeahawkFever wrote: ↑Wed Feb 04, 2026 10:06 pm Roger Craig got in, and very well deserved! Congrats to him!

There is one question I have though: Could he have gotten in sooner if the 49ers threepeated and the fumble in the 1990 NFC Championship Game never happens?

I'm thinking yes