Professional Football Researchers Association Forum

Heres my Modern Semi List Eric Allen Jared Allen Willie Anderson Tiki Barber Anquan Boldin Jahri Evans Antonio Gates Eddie George London Fletcher Rodney Harrison Torry Holt Luke Kuechly Eli Manning Steve Smith SR Joe Staley Terrell Suggs Earl Thomas Adam Vinatieri Hines Ward Ricky Watters Richmond W...

Brian wolf wrote: ↑Wed Sep 18, 2024 1:16 pm Thanks John ...

Will look at players that were ommitted, not that it matters. This new voting process I feel, will help first ballot candidates like Kuechly. Will it help strong candidates like Evans, Yanda or Thomas however?

I think it will help Evans kuechly yanda not sure about thomas

Tyrer is a very tricky case for very obvious reasons

heres my prelim list 1. Dick Anderson 2. Ken Anderson 3. Ed Budde 4. Maxie Baughan 5. Bill Bergey 6. Larry Brown (RB) 7. Joey Browner 8. Gary Collins 9. Charlie Conerly 10. Roger Craig 11. Nolan Cromwell 12. John David Crow 13. Lavern Dilweg 14. Boyd Dowler 15. Ox Emerson 16. Chuck Foreman 17. Bill ...

I hope I am wrong, but despite a screening and cutdown to 50 players, we will basically see the same 29 senior semi-finalists from last year with these players possibly left off for recentism. Only ties may help them. In Jeopardy? Powell Isbell Wistert Conerly Ties could help and I don't foresee a ...

Gotcha if you had to decide on your 50 Brian who would they be

Brian wolf wrote: ↑Tue Sep 10, 2024 8:53 pm I understand Robert. John mentions 60s receivers on this thread but Hennigan, Retzlaff, Jerry Smith and Lionel Taylor weren't on the preliminary list.

Lionel Taylor is on the list

Most of the guys Ive campaigned for over the years are on that list Brian so I'm satisfied

than wiiy Eli for Many Many Reasons was ranked too high in my opinion Gary? I don't really understand Carson>Huff and Brown>Hein. Hein is clearly either 1 or 2 IMO. Huff was a great MLB for a number of years, being Jim Brown's nemesis. The comparisons of the players are pretty straightforward, as t...

Honestly im in full agreement with John H 100% in terms of foreman not getting into the hall i agree with john on the fact his window was very very short and if it was longer than 5 years id be willing to endorse foreman for the hall