Professional Football Researchers Association Forum

I have always wanted a more transaparent election system for the Seniors, like semifinalists and finalists as in the open pool. not sure what you mean as one of the few recent improvements to the election process was a process by which the seniors committee vets a large preliminary list of senior c...

Even if he retired today, I would place him around 8th or so all time. I am always amazed more people don't realize and appreciate the historical career he has already had-not many other QBs in NFL history have 3 league championship (only 9 have achieved that) plus 2 NFL MVPs and he was the best pla...

Eagles One wrote: ↑Mon Aug 03, 2026 12:10 am During the Super Bowl era which excludes Brown, Halas, Lambeau, I would have Noll, Walsh, Gibbs and maybe Parcells ahead of Reid.

Not Bill Belichick???
Not Vince Lombardi???
Not Don Shula??
Not Tom Landry???

For me Reid sits around 10th or 11th all time, perhaps 8th or so in SB era

Cowboys 1980-1982, not as talented as 1970s team but with Danny White at QB they still went to three consecutive NFCC games

KC Chiefs of mid 60s to early 70s-great coach and plenty of PFHOFers yet just one SB

For me there remains plenty of uncertainty regarding the PFHOF resume for Josh Allen- I think he has a lot of work ahead of him to build a case but it could be done

its interesting to me that after 6 SBs in the 2020s decade, we have have just one team with 2 SBs in KC who would have the current edge. But with four more SBs to go, ReadJack could be right in that another team could yet emerge Plus 1960s 70s 80s 90s 00s 10s decades all had one team win 3+ champion...

Cowboys fan since 1977 and I followed the team very closely in early 1980s including that season, and I am not completely certain who would have won if DAL/CIN..keeping in mind that SB was very close game that could have gone either way-very possible DAL/CIN would have been the same. But talk about ...

Warner had two NFL MVP, one SB and got a 2nd team to a SB-his case is very unique and doubt it a model for others Same is going to be case for Jackson,even without a SB he will still have 2x MVP-are their any players in NFL history with multiple MVP not in Hall? If there is a new "standard"...

ReadJack made little error there as Eli was among 15 finalists for class of 2025 (1st year on ballot) and again for class of 2025-not just semi-finalist